Advanced - Deepstack + Blue Iris

Articles based on common support questions.
Post Reply
varghesesa
Posts: 20
Joined: Thu Jul 11, 2019 9:52 pm

Advanced - Deepstack + Blue Iris

Post by varghesesa » Mon Apr 12, 2021 12:07 am

Introduction

Blue Iris integrated directly with the Deepstack open source AI project with the 5.4.0 release. This is an on-prem only AI solution requested by many users.

Deepstack (deepstack.cc) was a private AI company (December 2018) located in Nigeria that recently open sourced their work (March 2019).

If you prefer to watch the webinar associated with this article, checkout our YouTube channel. Webinar name: Deepstack AI.

Benefits

The value of AI in surveillance is it improves accuracy to detect objects and reduces false alerts. AI will draw attention to activity that matters by identifying objects that could be missed by humans because of lack of attention or hard to see at night. AI also suppresses events that do not matter such as moving shadows from the wind, changes in sunlight, flies, birds, squirrels, rain etc. AI is becoming a very effective tool for outdoor cameras.

User experience

ai-alerts_optimized.png
ai-alerts_optimized.png (63.88 KiB) Viewed 3149 times
Icons:
  • Person
  • Car
  • Green check: AI confirmation, i.e. AI found an object, but no unique icon for object.
  • Flag: Used to easily filter clip list based on trigger events with AI confirmation.
  • Cancelled: nothing found
  • Occupied State per camera:
    Same object type: +/- 10% confidence level
    Same location: +/- 5%
    Time limit: 1 hour
    Object color (recently added)
    occupied state.PNG
    occupied state.PNG (47.29 KiB) Viewed 3147 times
    Gotcha: Sometimes occupied state results in false cancellations. In image above, second car is actually a different car so should have been alerted. Object color was recently added as another heuristic to measure so occupied state is even smarter. In addition, users can also turn off Static Objects for cameras. Camera settings -> Trigger tab -> Artificial Intelligence. Uncheck "Detect/ignore static objects".
Annotation colors
  • Orange: High level of confidence.
  • Yellow: Confidence level <67%
  • Blue: Found something, but occupied state cancelled alert.
  • Red: Cancelled alert based on "To cancel" field in Camera settings.
Static Objects (e.g. parked cars)
  • 5.4.3: Blue Iris AI detection takes into account motion detection before triggering an alert. The parked car should not alert!
Alerts or No alerts on specific objects

The Action Map for alerts have been extend so you can trigger alerts on specific objects. You can finally get the alert when the dog jumps on the couch! :)

Particularly handy if you are using facial recognition and want to be alerted only on unrecognized faces. Use the tag "unknown".

action map.PNG
action map.PNG (29.9 KiB) Viewed 3109 times


*** Checkpoint: Understand advantages of AI and the BI/Deepstack User Experience ***



Architecture

deepstack architecture.png
deepstack architecture.png (15.64 KiB) Viewed 3146 times


Deepstack AI Installation

Depending on your machine, you can choose the many Windows installation options. Below is the link to the Windows installation page. The CPU version is very easy to install. Just run the installer.

https://docs.deepstack.cc/windows/

Gotcha!: The DeepStack website needs some cleanup. There are pages on the site that point to a legacy installer that does not work! Stick to the URL above and you will be fine. In particular, the incorrect installer name is DeepStack.Installer.exe. My hunch is this version was created around 2019 before the company decided to open source their software. Another clue you have the wrong version is when you bring up the DeepStack splash page, Activation Key information is part of the page.


deepstack-wrong-activation-page_optimized.png
deepstack-wrong-activation-page_optimized.png (63.76 KiB) Viewed 1318 times

If you choose the wrong version, you will find BI cannot start DeepStack automatically. It cannot communicate with the server either with below errors in the Status -> Log.

deepstack error.PNG
deepstack error.PNG (22.95 KiB) Viewed 1316 times



Other useful Deepstack resources; I decided to use the GPU option because of my NVidia GPU.

According to the documentation, the GPU installation also requires CUDA 10.1 and cuDNN. The latest version of CUDA is 11.2. I took a chance with CUDA 11.2 and it seems to be working fine for me. I will share issues if I come across any. For those who are curious, CUDA is an API created by NVidia to make parallel programming on NVidia GPUs easier.

Run DeepStack Manually to Confirm Installation

I prefer to work in stages. For me a good first step is to install/run DeepStack manually. To start DeepStack manually, from a CMD prompt run the below command.

Code: Select all

deepstack --VISION-DETECTION True --PORT 82
The above command assumes you want to run DeepStack on port 82. Below is an image of the DeepStack console when the software is running correctly.

deepstack log.PNG
deepstack log.PNG (146.93 KiB) Viewed 1090 times

In addition to the console, you also get confirmation via the DeepStack browser confirmation page. From a browser go to localhost:82 (or port chosen to run the server)
deepstack.PNG
deepstack.PNG (196.52 KiB) Viewed 3218 times





Once installed, connect BI to Deepstack via Global settings -> AI tab as seen below.

AI global settings.png
AI global settings.png (55.35 KiB) Viewed 3038 times
  • Select "Use DeepStack server on IP/port".
  • Specify which port to use for DeepStack. 82 is the default. As long as it is NOT the same port as the BI web server you are fine. I'm assuming you installed DeepStack on your BI machine, thus IP Address = 127.0.0.1. BI does allow the ability to run DeepStack on a separate server.
  • DO NOT check Auto start/stop with Blue Iris.
  • Jump to Blue Iris AI Camera settings section below and turn on DeepStack for one camera.
  • Check for any errors in Status -> log.
    When working correctly, the motion event in the log should be followed by a DeepStack response as seen below.
    deepstack status log.PNG
    deepstack status log.PNG (7.86 KiB) Viewed 1046 times
  • Check the DeepStack console as well. Are requests / response being processed by DeepStack?

Confirmed: DeepStack is running. BI is talking to DeepStack successfully. Now you can automate start/stop of DeepStack. (optional)
  • Check "Auto start/stop with Blue Iris.
    Best to install DeepStack in default location (C:\DeepStack). If you choose a different location, please specify accordingly.
  • Stop the DeepStack you started manually. May need to restart machine just to make sure all processes run by DeepStack are shutdown.
  • Hit Start now.
  • Use Test in browser link to confirm Deepstack is running.
  • Similar to above, confirm one camera is processing DeepStack motion events properly.
  • If you want to play with Facial recognition, you can activate the feature as well.
Distributed Systems
It is feasible to run BI on one machine and Deepstack on a completely separate machine. A separate machine could mean a completely separate hardware server or a VM or a Dockers container.

One user stated he did so successfully by running a Docker container in an Ubuntu 18.04 VM. In his implementation the IP Address for the Docker container was 10.32.1.9.

The docker command was:

Code: Select all

docker run -d \
        --name=deepstack \
        -p 80:5000 \
        -v /opt/deepstack-storage:/datastore:rw \
        -e "VISION-DETECTION=True" \
        -e "VISION-FACE=True" \
        deepquestai/deepstack
/opt/deepstack-storage was the folder where Docker was allowed to permanently store things.

Once setup, similar to the non-distributed system (above), check/confirm that you can access the Deepstack confirmation page from a browser on the BI server (Test in browser link). In BI, the AI settings based on the Docker IP Address mentioned above would be:
deepstack-ai-settings.png
deepstack-ai-settings.png (44.03 KiB) Viewed 1381 times

If you see traffic on the AI machine but no objects in BI, you likely did not enable the vision detection.



*** Checkpoint: Deepstack is installed and can communicate with BI server! ***



Blue Iris AI Camera settings

Camera settings -> Trigger tab -> Artificial Intelligence

ai-camera-settings_optimized.png
ai-camera-settings_optimized.png (127.53 KiB) Viewed 3050 times


List of Objects Available for detection
Best to check deepstack.cc for current list of objects.

Code: Select all

person,   bicycle,   car,   motorcycle,   airplane,
bus,   train,   truck,   boat,   traffic light,   fire hydrant,   stop_sign,
parking meter,   bench,   bird,   cat,   dog,   horse,   sheep,   cow,   elephant,
bear,   zebra, giraffe,   backpack,   umbrella,   handbag,   tie,   suitcase,
frisbee,   skis,   snowboard, sports ball,   kite,   baseball bat,   baseball glove,
skateboard,   surfboard,   tennis racket, bottle,   wine glass,   cup,   fork,
knife,   spoon,   bowl,   banana,   apple,   sandwich,   orange, broccoli,   carrot,
hot dog,   pizza,   donut,   cake,   chair,   couch,   potted plant,   bed, dining table,
toilet,   tv,   laptop,   mouse,   remote,   keyboard,   cell phone,   microwave,
oven,   toaster,   sink,   refrigerator,   book,   clock,   vase,   scissors,   teddy bear,
hair dryer, toothbrush.


Alerts

Blue Iris before Artificial Intelligence

BI before AI.PNG
BI before AI.PNG (27.67 KiB) Viewed 3121 times
Use Case: Better safe than sorry. AI is great but I rather be notified on all motion alerts.

No Fire on Alert.PNG
No Fire on Alert.PNG (45.04 KiB) Viewed 3118 times


Use Case: So many false alerts. I trust my AI and its notifications.

Fire on Alert.PNG
Fire on Alert.PNG (48.21 KiB) Viewed 3118 times


Use Case: I trust my AI but I still need my other alerts like mqtt commands to trigger (home automation).

Fire on Alert Both.PNG
Fire on Alert Both.PNG (54.42 KiB) Viewed 3069 times


*** Checkpoint: DeepStack Configuration complete. BI server sending meaningful alerts based on AI. ***




Fine tuning / Trouble-shooting
  • Turn off "Hide cancelled alerts on timeline and 'all alerts'. Camera settings -> Trigger tab -> Artificial Intelligence. It's much easier to find missed alerts through the clip list. Take advantage of BI functionality.
  • Set recording to "When triggered". Camera settings -> Record tab. Uncheck Combine or cut video each. This way a new BVR is created for each trigger. Because you have a BVR for each trigger event, it's easy to replay a missd alert/false alert and tweak your motion settings and observe if the tweaks improve your alerts. If you cannot figure out an issue, it is easy to send the bvr to support for review!
  • Make sure "Burn label mark-up onto alert images" is on. Camera settings -> Trigger tab -> Artificial Intelligence. Default is on. Not sure why anyone would NOT want to see the AI annotations.
  • Turn on Motion overlays. Camera settings -> Trigger tab -> Motion Sensor. Highlight: Rectangles or Highlight / Rectangle
Artificial intelligence is not perfect. Motion detection identified movement and it's obvious to any human the image below is a car. Not always easy for AI.

Tracing DeepStack to make sure it is working between your camera <--> BI <--> DeepStack

Below are the steps I took to determine the problem is with limitations to the AI model and not BI.

With the "Burn label mark-up onto alert images" AI setting, easy to get the trigger image as seen below from the Alerts tab. You can right click on alert in clip list -> Open containing folder. Windows explorer should point to the file containing the trigger image.

deepstack-headlights_optimized.png
deepstack-headlights_optimized.png (163.76 KiB) Viewed 1046 times

You can see for yourself in above image what is going on. BI motion sensors identified the moving object, no problem. DeepStack said this is not a car (no annotation).

deepstack miss.PNG
deepstack miss.PNG (30.74 KiB) Viewed 1046 times

If DeepStack saw a car (a different alert below), you would see the annotation. The overlap of the DeepStack object and the Motion detection object further confirms the static object test, i.e. it's a moving car, not a parked car because of motion and DeepStack object overalap.
deepstack alert image confirmed.png
deepstack alert image confirmed.png (168.06 KiB) Viewed 1019 times

And being paranoid, I also wanted to make sure DeepStack was running ok. So I also checked the Status -> Log for any errors. :)

deepstack status log.PNG
deepstack status log.PNG (7.86 KiB) Viewed 1046 times

You see the response to the user appears at 12:46:51. I told BI to send 5 samples to DeepStack. 12:46 + 5s = 12:46:51.

deepstack settings five samples.PNG
deepstack settings five samples.PNG (7.02 KiB) Viewed 1046 times

With the motion overlays combined with the timestamp checks combined with no Status -> Log errors, I am convinced the integration did it's job and the reality was DeepStack got confused by the headlights and kept returning no car!

Does this mean I am going to resign myself to missed alerts due to headlights? Heck no! I'm going to tweak my Motion settings in order to try capturing motion much further up the street. This will allow me to get more samples of the car for DeepStack to analyze and hopefully alert on cars with headlights on. The power of Motion sensors with AI!

Analyze Image with Deepstack
  • Now you can find out what Deepstack recognizes when processing an alert. Great tool if you are wondering why an alert was missed.
  • Select an alert and start playback.
  • Stop the alert clip where you want Deepstack to analyze the image.
  • Take a snapshot. Saving to the clipboard directory (default) is fine.
  • From the clip list, select the jpg image that you just created. (may need to select clipboard icon on the clip list)
  • Right click -> Analyze image with Deepstack.
  • See the annotation.
    deepstack analyze.PNG
    deepstack analyze.PNG (227.69 KiB) Viewed 2342 times
I'm getting missed alerts. How do I find out what Deepstack analyzed?

Simple. Uncheck 'Fire "On alert" actions only when confirmed". This will result in BI sending all the alerts like before. Send yourself an email, SMS or Push notification with the attached image (which is the image used to process the event). If there are no annotations, then Deepstack missed the object.


Microsoft Process Explorer

A new debugging tool is now part of the arsenal for tech saavy users. Ever wondered which program has a particular file or directory open? Now you can find out with Microsoft Process Explorer. Process Explorer shows you information about which handles and DLLs processes have opened or loaded.

https://docs.microsoft.com/en-us/sysint ... s-explorer

The link above provides instructions on how to download and install (zip file). The application comes with a Help file to understand the program. You can use this tool to see if DeepStack is running. It should be shown as "sever.exe" beneath BlueIris.exe (assuming BI is set to start DeepStack) under services.


Gotchas

Gotcha 8: 2021-May-19
DeepStack is on (or believed to be on). However, no AI alerts appear in clip list. And no errors in the Status->Log!

We are getting reports that users have DeepStack running based on the DeepStack splash page popping up. However, NO Deepstack annotations appear when they should. It's as if DeepStack is not even turned on. Clips list looks like below. Only motion annotations
no deepstack cliplist.png
no deepstack cliplist.png (43.42 KiB) Viewed 1090 times

Once DeepStack is activated, you should receive AI annotations. Even with no objects, the "nothing found" AI annotation appears!
nothing found.PNG
nothing found.PNG (29.18 KiB) Viewed 1090 times

If DeepStack were turned on, the clip list would look like below when objects were found.
deepstack running.png
deepstack running.png (69.3 KiB) Viewed 1090 times


First, confirm you have DeepStack turned ON for the camera you are debugging! Camera settings -> Trigger tab -> Artificial Intelligence. Also check Global settings -> AI tab.

Assuming your settings are correct, run DeepStack manually to see if requests are being sent to DeepStack from BI.
  • Uncheck Auto start/stop in Global settings -> AI.
  • Restart BI to make sure no DeepStack processes are still running. DeepStack could be unstable if trying to do so manually with all the additional processes that DeepStack spawns (server.exe, python.exe, redis-server.exe).

    deepstack processes.PNG
    deepstack processes.PNG (6.46 KiB) Viewed 1086 times
  • Start DeepStack manually from the command line. "deepstack --VISION-DETECTION True --PORT 82". Port 82 is used by default but if you chose a different port (Global settings -> AI tab), specify the same number in command line.
From the console, every time you trigger the camera or camera triggers on its own, observe whether a new request appears in the command window.
deepstack log.PNG
deepstack log.PNG (146.93 KiB) Viewed 1090 times

Gotcha 7: 2021-May-19 Update:
Deepstack is running but sometimes BI responds server not running


The below logs show a successful Deepstack response at 1:09:15. Then at 1:09:46 BI states Deepstack is unreachable, however user confirmed Deepstack is still running.

Code: Select all

5/12/2021 1:09:46 PM Oby1Cam: DeepStack: Not running or unreachable (84)
5/12/2021 1:09:45 PM Oby1Cam: MOTION (79)
5/12/2021 1:09:15 PM Ofy1Cam: DeepStack: Alert cancelled (nothing found) (83)
5/12/2021 1:09:09 PM Ofy1Cam: MOTION (75)
The fix:
First confirm all Software Security Exemptions (e.g. Windows Defender) have been applied. The Windows Tuning Article provides details.
viewtopic.php?f=12&t=2080

The unreachable message occurs if DS does not respond on the IP:port that you specify. If this is not due to issues with security software, perhaps DS is having other issues. I do see an occasional DS state where it is not responding.

BI is now detecting Deepstack not running or unreachable states and restarts DeepStack behind the scenes (assuming BI is set to start/stop DeepStack). This should fix the issue without any user interaction needed.



Gotcha 6: BI Status Log Error - Deepstack not running or unreachable
If BI cannot communicate with Deepstack, BI will let you know.
Assuming you have Auto start/stop with BI enabled, simple fix is stop Deepstack if it's running and restart BI.
BI cannot talk to Deepstack.png
BI cannot talk to Deepstack.png (6.37 KiB) Viewed 2118 times


Gotcha 5: High CPU usage with Deepstack.
AI / Deepstack is very computationally heavy. If your CPU usage jumps and you don't have a GPU the best you can do is throttle the calls to Deepstack.
  • Turn on Deepstack only for outdoor cameras. BI motion settings are usually fine for indoor cameras.
  • Reduce number of images sampled per alert.
  • Tighten your BI motion sensor settings so cameras do not trigger an alert so frequently.

Gotcha 4: Deepstack missing obvious objects.

Shout out to our users for sharing issues and solutions!

For some reason, the BlueIris software is ignoring what the Deepstack server says in terms of confidence and the label. This seems to happen during the second, third or sometimes fourth image that Deepstack analyzes. I have confirmed with a packet capture that despite these additional images being sent back to the BlueIris software with a successful response, BlueIris ignores it and goes to cancel the alert. I confirm these images meet the criteria of the minimum confidence percentage and "to confirm". I would like to also mention that if DeepStack responds back with a prediction that is within the criteria on the first image, it works OK.

Fix: I just needed to change the keyframe interval to be the same value as the FPS so it is equal to 1.00 (as displayed from Blue Iris). The detection is working much better now. See Camera stream optimization article for details.

Alternative fix: If for some reason you cannot adjust the key frame interval on the camera, identify the current key frame interval (Status -> Cameras tab). If the value is 0.25, i.e. 1/4, i.e. 1 key frame every 4s, then set the pre-trigger buffer (Camera settings -> Record tab) greater than or equal to 4s. This will guarantee BI at least one key frame to process.



Gotcha 3: Deepstack always returning nothing found. (Another shout out to the community for making everyone smarter)
This could imply the Deepstack server is returning server errors and BI is just reporting back "nothing found".
BI will eventually report the Deepstack errors in the Status->log to make users aware of the issue easier.

Until done so, one user creatively used Postman to identify the issue. If you are a developer, you are probably familiar with Postman. It's a very popular tool that helps test and debug APIs. If new to Postman, lots of content on the internet how to use it. By using Postman, the user discovered object detection requests to Postman were returning 500 error codes. 500 errors mean the server had a problem processing the request.

FYI, 400 errors mean the request to Deepstack is not correct. For those new to Postman, a 400 error means the request you created in Postman to send to Deepstack is not correct. You need to first make sure you are sending correct requests to Deepstack.

Once the user realized their Deepstack installation was not working correctly, they reinstalled Deepstack. Deepstack does provide error logs, "C:\Users\[Username]\AppData\Local\DeepStack\logs" (%LOCALAPPDATA%\DeepStack\logs). Understanding the logs were challenging so best course of action was to try reinstalling Deepstack.

User also noted uninstalling Deepstack may not flush out all the files. The user went back into the installation directory (C:\DeepStack) and manually deleted any remaining files.

Furthermore, user noted, it's good to go into task manager and make sure any old Deepstack processes are not running. You can go into Task Manager and kill any of the following processes: server.exe, python.exe, redis-server-exe if they exist.

FYI, installing / using AI Tool for debugging may be worthwhile as BI continues to build out the debugging capabilities. In AI Tool, error messages will pop up right away if old Deepstack versions are still running.
ai tool error.PNG
ai tool error.PNG (4.89 KiB) Viewed 1745 times

Another clue that Deepstack is not running properly is by running Deepstack manually and observing the response time in the console. If Deepstack is taking 1m to respond, there is probably something wrong.
deepstack response time.PNG
deepstack response time.PNG (28.81 KiB) Viewed 1745 times

Gotcha 2: Front door camera

Front door view has the road and therefore a lot of unnecessary alerts. All you really want are people coming to the house or property.

front door.jpg
front door.jpg (154.09 KiB) Viewed 3112 times

So you create a zone in front of your house to reduce the noise from the road.

b_optimized.png
b_optimized.png (158.66 KiB) Viewed 3112 times

No alerts! The problem is the camera will trigger when a person's feet crosses Zone B. The image being processed by Deepstack is just the feet! So Deepstack will often return nothing found.

The fix! Make sure to always define a Zone A which is the overall area of interest on the camera. The image processed by Deepstack is the overlap of all the zones, thus the entire person is sent to Deepstack for processing and the appropriate alert is sent.

a_optimized.png
a_optimized.png (125.22 KiB) Viewed 3112 times


One important point that I forgot to mention in the Webinar but did come up in the Q&A is how to tell BI to only be concerned with motion in Zone B??? Simple, see below. By setting "Object crosses zones" to B, I am telling BI to only worry about motion in Zone B. Notice with AI, I uncheck "Object travels" and "Object size exceeds" settings. With AI, the motion sensor settings can usually be simplified!

Zone B setting.PNG
Zone B setting.PNG (12.79 KiB) Viewed 1983 times

Gotcha 1: Person detection & Facial detection

Keep in mind the current implementation of Deepstack runs in series, not in parallel. So if you have both activated in Deepstack, Deepstack will alert on person detection first and never alert on facial recognition. Most people would probably think Deepstack would first discover the person and then proceed to recognize the face, but this does not seem to be the case.

Person detected in image below even though person detection and facial recognition was activated.
person and facial.jpg
person and facial.jpg (131.09 KiB) Viewed 3111 times
With just facial recognition activated.
facial.jpg
facial.jpg (114.07 KiB) Viewed 3111 times


Next steps / Submit a ticket
  • Describe issue.
  • Status -> Log errors
  • Status -> Camera tab. Need to know the health of the camera streams.
  • Any steps you have taken so far to resolve the issue. This will help us gain insight as to the problem.
  • Screenshot of Global settings -> AI tab.
  • Screenshot of Alerts in Clips List so we understand what BI is sensing currently.
  • Camera settings. Camera settings -> General tab -> Export
Post Reply